and the Problem of Sufficiency.” Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective 2 (8): 121-138.

Social epistemology should be truth-centred, argues Goldman. Social epistemology should capture the ‘logic of everyday practices ’ and describe socially ‘situated ’ reasoning, says Fuller. Starting from Goldman’s vision of epistemology, this paper aims to argue for Fuller’s contention. Social epistemology cannot focus solely on the truth because the truth can be got in lucky ways. The same too could be said for reliability. Adding a second layer of epistemic evaluation helps only insofar as the reasons thus specified are appropriately connected to reliability. These claims are first made in abstract, and then developed with regard to our practice of trusting testimony, where an epistemological investigation into the grounds of reliability must inevitably detail the ‘logic of everyday practices’. Section 1 “Mainstream epistemologists are lovers of truth; at least they are comfortable doin